5 Tricks to Get Your Male Self Out the Door in Nail Polish – STEEL YOURSELF!!
by Scott Gents on Jan 20, 2013 • 12:27 pm 22 CommentsHey everyone – and welcome to the 1st anniversary of this little screed. Based on the response I’ve received over the past 12 months, I think I can pretty reasonably say this has been a successful effort so far.
I think I’ve gotten my word out to a lot of people who were looking for new perspectives in the polish-o-sphere, and its been interesting to see all the new male nail blogs that have sprouted up since this one was born on January 18th, 2012. I’m not claiming to have inspired those – only stating that it’s cool to see that there is some semblance of a trend.
As far as I know, there were only two others in existence when I established One Gent’s Ten (‘Men and Nail Polish‘, ‘LacquerMan‘ (by ONE day!)), and I discovered those only after I started paying attention to who was out there.
Anyway, it’s been very cool and a ton of fun feeling out my niche and checking out the many, many positive responses I gotten from the world. I’ve got almost 1,000 comments on all of my posts so far – almost all of them positive. How cool is that?!
Many thanks to Ms Gents for all of her support, and to the several guest posters I’ve been proud to feature here.
I plan to keep posting, and I hope to feature more posts on the idea of men wearing nail polish, rather than just posting swatch/reviews all the time.
We’ll see what happens – this road is paved with the best intentions…let’s hope it doesn’t lead to hell!
Alright, so I’m sure you’re waiting with baited breath for my 5 tricks. These tricks were the ‘logical armor’ that I used to prepare myself for what was, in my mind, the very scary prospect of breaking a gender norm that seemed completely set in stone.
These have helped me get out the door with my nails painted those times when I’ve fallen into self-doubt or started second-guessing my choice to wear the nail polish.
Since these concepts were so helpful to me, I thought it would be a good idea to share them with any of you guys out there who are enviously looking at the girl next door’s nail colors and thinking “I’d love to paint my nails like hers, but that’s just not something I could pull off…”
1. Try Neutrals.
One of the first colors I wore outside my own four walls was a neutral – OPI Fiji Weejee Fawn. I wore this color with confidence out in public, and not just once – but many times.
I liked this neutral because if I looked directly at my nails, it was apparent they were polished (with a very pretty color), but if you weren’t looking directly at them up close, they didn’t jump out and scream “My nails are painted!!” In fact, I wore this color so much, that I’ve never featured it on my blog, because in my subconscious mind, it was always ‘old hat.’ I should remedy that sometime soon, considering the invaluable service this color did for me.
Anyway, this same principle applies to all neutral, flesh-tone colors. It’s much easier to slip by undetected when your nail color closely matches your overall skin tone.
The logic here is that by exposing yourself to increasing levels of perceived risk, you’ll be able to work your way up to full-fledged free wearing as you realize for yourself that there’s actually no risk at all (or at least very, very little). With neutral colors, you can get your feet wet with low risk of unwanted attention.
I will caveat, though, that you need to have your skin and cuticles well taken care of, otherwise the polish will just jump out and clash with the overall appearance of your hands.
2. Go with a traditional “guy color.”
Choose something drab, dark, or matte (or all three). These colors will be obvious, but won’t raise eyebrows because people are much more used to seeing these types of colors on men. Anything dubbed “vampy” will work great as a traditional guy color.
Of course, as you know, I bristle at the idea of colors being separated as “for men” or “not for men,” but for the purpose of this article, think of this from the perspective of the average guy or girl on the street who will be looking at your nails. If you’re worried about upsetting people (which you shouldn’t be), you can start wearing polish by using colors that most people won’t be shocked to see on your nails.
Over New Year’s, I wore Essie “Smokin Hot,” which is a traditional guy color (muted grey-black-purple), but I added a glitter accent nail to keep it interesting.
No one even made an inkling of a comment, except for the guy putting my wristband on at the door to the club, and he complimented me without sarcasm.
3. Bring accepting friends, or go somewhere accepting.
This one is pretty self-explanatory. I usually have Ms Gents with me, and she’s awesome about helping me to feel comfortable with my nails done. The more people who know about your nails and accept it, the better you’ll feel about showing them off. This applies whether they’re actually with you or not. When you’re just starting out, however, having them with you helps tremendously.
Places to go could be anywhere that you know open-minded people congregate. Groups that lean left politically tend to be safer for this type of thing. Think college campuses, gentrified urban areas, and moderate-to-densely populated suburban neighborhoods.
4. Flash your nails in neutral territory.
What the heck does this mean?
Here’s what it means: go on vacation, go on a cruise, or go visit an accepting friend somewhere far from home, and show off your nails out in public there.
This way you can get first-hand experience in the way people react (or don’t react) to your nail polish. My bet is that they won’t react at all, or they’ll compliment you.
At the same time, doing it where you don’t know anyone will reduce the chance that you’ll run into someone you know, or someone from work, who may not be clued-in to your off-duty nail polish interests. This way you can work your way up to sharing this part of your life with those hometown people on your own terms, if you ever choose to.
5. Ask yourself, “Whats the worst that could happen?”
Be realistic here!! When I’m really doubting myself, this is one of the most effective tricks I’ve found to help me overcome those doubts.
I’m kind of embarrassed to say it, but I learned this technique from watching one of those shows about people with compulsions/obsessions. The treatment employed for people with irrational fears (fear of flying, fear of throwing out useless knickknacks, etc) is called “exposure therapy,” and it involves forcing the patient to do the thing they’re afraid of, and experience firsthand the non-result.
The patients are asked to share their ‘catastrophic thoughts’ with the therapist, who usually points out why those thoughts should be dismissed. The reason for dismissing these thoughts is usually that there’s no reasonable situation where these fears will ever come to pass.
Anyway, this technique has worked wonders for me in getting outside with my nails done. Ms Gents and I often jokingly say ‘tell me your catastrophic thoughts’ whenever I get into a funk and can’t convince myself its ok to wear my nail polish.
However, whenever I reason it out, these are the worst things that I can imagine happening:
- Someone gives me a weird look
- Someone says something rude
- I experience panic, as a result of thinking about one of those two situations coming to pass.
So, I’m hoping you see how silly that is.
I hope none of you are worried about physical violence. While I won’t completely rule that out – I would have to say the probability of such an event is less than 1/10 of 1 percent in modern, westernized societies.
With the current climate of acceptance and the widespread pop-culture celebration of “alternative lifestyles,” a guy wearing nail polish should probably be seen as passé by 99.99 percent of the population of western society.
So, there you have it! Steel yourself for the slings and arrows with these techniques, then go out and conquer your fears. I promise you’ll realize your fears are irrational in most situations.
Disclaimer: These tricks don’t really apply to the workplace, which has its own set of rules. But for doing things outside of professional settings – these approaches should work wonders!












22 comments
Charmy says:
Jan 20, 2013
You’re awesome, keep it up! (:
Scott Gents says:
Jan 20, 2013
Thank you!
Rochelle says:
Jan 20, 2013
Very well written, I think this is all true.
And while work has it’s own set of rules, I’d say you should be able to go by what the girls are allowed to wear. Some jobs it’s no polish at all, others it has to be “work-safe” colors. But most companies have huge “no gender discrimination” policies. If you’re keeping your nails up as nicely as any of the ladies hopefully it wouldn’t be an issue.
Scott Gents says:
Jan 20, 2013
Rochelle,
That’s a great insight, and I think I would agree that the vast majority of employers would not openly discriminate against a man for wearing tasteful polish.
With that said, I think openly wearing polish would hurt most men’s career advancement, sadly, and particularly with some of the more ‘old school’ members of upper management.
In other words, they wouldn’t fire you, but you’d probably notice fewer opportunities coming your way if you were to openly polish your nails as a man.
Only after it has been widely accepted in society for a long period of time would it become safe for men to wear polish at work. Heck, wearing earrings is still quite taboo for men in most professional settings. It sucks, but that’s the reality.
Thanks for your thoughtful comment!!
Inky Whiskers says:
Jan 20, 2013
Bravo! With all the gender bending you & the other guys bravely wearing their polish with pride are doing, it’s only a matter of time before people accept polish on men as ‘normal’. <3
Scott Gents says:
Jan 20, 2013
Great point, Inky!
I can only hope it becomes as normal as it is for girls, and soon!
John says:
Jan 21, 2013
Hey! Love the blog, thanks for all your posts and hard work! It’s given me the impetus to just start venturing out on the weekends with fingernails painted, where previously I’ve just been doing toes.
I also went to work last week with an American manicure using Essie Marshmallow for tips and Essie Allure over top. It’s a nice, natural look that isn’t completely obvious, while at the same time being totally classy and, of course, traditionally girly.
It was actually a very interesting experience to be having a conversation with someone and notice their eyes flick down a few times to the nails, as if they were first noticing, then actually confirming what they noticed. I got a bit of a taste for what women often justly complain about… “hey, my eyes are up here!”
Scott Gents says:
Jan 21, 2013
Hey there John!
I’m so happy to hear that not only have you enjoyed the blog, by that it’s also inspired you to explore public nail polish wearing!
Keep showing off those nails, and keep reading!
Andrew says:
Jan 22, 2013
Scott, I’m glad you posted this piece. Your blog seems much more “real” than a few other “men in polish” sites.
I have just done my toes in pale pink for the past 6 months. I have had my fingernails buffed for years without fanfare but I’d like to try the pale pink on them and go crazy with my toes for starters but I’m scared to death about what others would say. Your words of encouragement help tremendously! (I have a mani/pedi scheduled this weekend and that OPI color is on my to do list.)
Leacroft says:
Jan 22, 2013
Brilliant read, as always.
Will endeavour to try out some of these, very soon, if I can find the courage!
Michelle S says:
Jan 24, 2013
I know I’m a bit late posting, sorry. But sometimes I just wonder what is wrong with us as a society. ITS JUST BLOOMING NAIL POLISH! U don’t have to be scared of it like u should a gun in ur face, it doesn’t make u gay or weird or any other such nonsense. I honestly scratch my head sometimes and really feel for u guys/men who just want to do something u love. I hope it it gets easier for u real soon and carry on regardless I say! Stuff em all! ;-D
Hector of Grillednails says:
Jan 27, 2013
I really love this article. I go to a very liberal college, which does still remain a contradiction here in right wing Texas, but I strive to wear polish on the daily. I love polish, and most others compliment me on my designs. Some say it is because im a gay male, but I say it is because I love polish because they are not mutually exclusive. No one should have to be gay to wear polish, nor feminine, it is paint, and should be as casual as wearing shoes or shirts. Everyone. should be able to wear things they like, with good taste too!
Scott Gents says:
Jan 27, 2013
Awesome comment, Hector! Everything you said was ON POINT! Also I just checked out your blog, and your nails are looking awesome. Email me at onegents@gmail.com if you’d like to arrange a guest post here!
Charlie says:
Feb 12, 2013
Love this post!! I wear my nails with clear polish at work – they’re not perfectly manicured like yours but they are clean and very neat and more than slightly too long for a guy but I find that only the girls ever notice and usually are very positive and often openly ‘jealous’ – a few want to paint my nails for me!! Despite working in a strictly equal opportunities workplace, it’s a very macho environment (by virtue of the services my organisation provides – he says ambiguously) and i don’t think colour would go down well at all. I find this a little frustrating, but work, as you say, has its own rules.
Option4 on your list is very liberating – you can be fairly outrageous – sure you get a few stares, but honestly, who cares, you’ll never see these people again! If someone thinks youre gay or whatever then it’s irrelevant, unlike in your home environment where you’d be forever justifying yourself. When I was new to the city where I now live I used to be far more effeminate and quirky with how I dress – it was like a permanent option 4, but after 5 years, it’s too small a place – I’m always bumping into friends, colleagues present and past, so I’m now a bit more circumspect which is a shame.
As a straight married man who is pretty comfortable with my feminine side, I find it frustrating that I have to keep things on the down low – dammit I like pretty nails and high heeled boots too!!
Steve D says:
Mar 16, 2013
Hey Mr Gents,
I was just searching around and I found this… As a guy, just thought I would say too that I really like painting my nails. Even though they’re seen as feminine, reds and pinks are my favourites, but I’m liking vivid yellows and oranges and dark blues a lot more lately too.
I really wish I had more courage to wear out in public. You’re right in your other post that some girls really dig it and it would be a great way to find the ones that do. Maybe if I liked in a bigger city…
It’s also such a stress reliever too and I always love the look of it on my toes and fingernails. So keep on painting I say, and keep on being a real inspiration.
Thank you Scott :-)
P.s. Love the blog layout and design too!
Brad says:
Apr 5, 2013
Thanks for a great article… I’ve worn nail polish out in public many times… always a huge rush and I have trouble not trying to hide it (especially when guys are around as I feel they’d be more judgemental)… The worst that could happen for me is different than the 3 you identified… “that someone I know sees me with nail polish”. I’m still very uncomfortable around guys with my nails painted, but I’m getting more and more comfortable around girls for whatever reason. Its funny… I usually try to make sure a girl sees them, whereas I hide them from guys.
andy says:
Apr 6, 2013
great article
I have worn clear or neutral colors for several years and no one notices
Went to London a week ago and had a manicure, and had them painted royal blue.
I am a licensed professional.
Went back to the office and to Court no one said a word
Some of the female staff said that they looked nice
confidence is the key
if you think it is alright then it is alright
KEV's EV's says:
Apr 14, 2013
Good idea, I LOVE nail polish, but im only 12, but I’ll take your advice and try doing it after i can get over my embarrassment to my parents and friends.
KEV's EV's says:
Apr 19, 2013
Should i do it?
JJ says:
May 9, 2013
I say GO FOR IT! BUT you may want to try something like this:
paint just your pinky on your left hand. use a neutral color. wear it for a week or so. if someone makes a comment just you saw johnny dep or something and you thought it looked good so you tried it. just say you forgot about it after it dried and WHY? DOES IT BOTHER YOU?
after that try booth pinkies in the same color for another week or so. then play it by ear. no negative comments after 2 to 3 weeks …. go for all 10. after experimenting for a couple weeks of all 10 in neutral color darken them a little and progress from there.
you’ll get 6 months into this and you’ll wear anything you want
good luck!
JJ says:
May 9, 2013
Something I forgot to mention. i’ll bet that when you get into it for 6 months you’ll get a couple copy cats. you’re not the only guy that wants to try this.
jj says:
May 10, 2013
by the way. having trouble with your parents acceptance is a good sign. to me, this means your parents mean a lot to you. they have done their job well. they have passed to you that all decisions have effects. the one we are discussing will affect only you BUT you evidently gave it some thought. go hug your mom and dad they sound like good people. do what makes you happy without affecting others. test the waters, be brave and always love your mom and dad. GO FOR IT !